1.2 Community Scientists: Who are they? What do they do?

This lesson contains an overview of Community Scientist programs including what team members may be asked to do and the evolution of community science. Some questions to consider while completing this lesson include:

  • What is the role of a Community Scientist in society?
  • Who can be a Community Scientist?
  • What are common activities in which a Community Scientists can engage?

Learning Objectives

  • List some of the activities in which Community Scientists may engage
  • Describe the role Community Scientists may play in influencing research priorities and development
  • Discuss an example of how Community Science has furthered the research of a rare disease

Video Tutorial

Note: The video refers to participants and/or the program as “Citizen Scientist,” which was the previous name of the Community Scientist Program.

Presented By: Janet Brishke

Extended Video Captions- 1.2: Community Scientists: Who are they? What do they do?

Slide 1
Hi. My name is Janet Brishke, and today I will be talking to you about who Citizen Scientists are and what they do.

Slide 2
Today I will discuss who Citizen Scientists are and the roles they play in research, as well as the different levels of engagement for Citizen Scientists.

Slide 3
Citizen Scientists are members of the community who engage with researchers and bring their own life and personal experiences to the research process. It is important that Citizen Scientists be representative of the community they come from. This means that the group should be varied in gender, age, race, ethnicity, and cultural representation.
While some Citizen Scientists may relate to the patient’s perspective in a medical research study because of personal experiences, team members are considered to be community representatives, or “stakeholders” in research outcomes. It is perfectly acceptable to bring your experience as a patient or caretaker of a patient with a specific health experience to the table; however, you are never obligated to discuss your own health conditions or experiences.

Slide 4
Citizen Science projects empower individuals by inviting them to be involved in a scientific or observational activity, and then giving them a way to report their findings. Some of these types of activities are:
Monitoring the environment and reporting things like air or light pollution
Observing the health of plants and animals through things like the Audubon bird count or noting migration patterns of birds,
Reporting on the weather through posting updates to National Weather Service field office social media accounts
It’s a big transition from reporting hail through a Facebook page to being involved in medical research. So let’s take a look at how Citizen Scientists started participating in this work.

Slide 5
Sharon Terry’s situation is one example of a parent or patient taking control of a situation in order to make a difference in health care. Sharon has two children who have a rare genetic disease called PXE. She brought them to a researcher to have their blood drawn, and when she wanted to talk about the genetic results and to receive a copy of the information, she was told that the information did not belong to her. She questioned why science should be limited to, or “owned by” scientific professionals.    
In 1995, her family teamed up with a doctor to create a web site called PXE International. This site helps people around the world learn and share information about PXE. The web site has a database where patients can upload their own medical tests (which are then de-identified so that no one will know which information belongs to whom), and the database is shared with researchers who are willing to share results of their research with the patients. This database was created after several experiences with researchers who did not want to share data with the patients they were researching. This is known as patient-powered research, and it can be very empowering.

Slide 6
[diagram showing three levels of engagement—Minimal, Moderate, and Sustained—progressing from low to high in both engagement and complexity/frequency of assigned tasks]
There are different levels of engagement that a Citizen Scientist can experience, and over time your role may shift along this spectrum. Let’s look at what different types of engagement mean for Citizen Scientists.

Slide 7
[slide listing minimal engagement activities: reviewing outcomes, recruitment materials, informed consent forms, and research abstracts]
In a minimal engagement scenario, a group or a subgroup of Citizen Scientists may be asked to advise a researcher on a grant proposal that is under development. Generally, your input will be sought in the areas of the proposal that you as a community member would best be able to offer input on. For example, a researcher might show you a list of outcomes (or results) that the research team plans to measure, and then asks if those outcomes would be important to you if you were a patient in the study. Or a researcher may show you recruitment materials like a flyer and ask if it was something you would respond to if you saw it hanging in your doctor’s office. A researcher could also ask you to read the informed consent form or research abstract, which is a summary of the project, to see if it makes sense from a patient’s point of view.

Slide 8
[slide listing moderate engagement activities: contributing to research questions, evaluating recruitment feasibility, and reviewing dissemination plans]
At a moderate level of engagement, you might be asked to help create the research question or give your opinion on whether the research question is worth exploring. You might also be asked to give your opinion on whether you think the plan for asking people to be involved in the study (known as study recruitment) makes sense to you. An example of this could be when a proposed study asks the participants involved to come back every week throughout winter to have their blood drawn. The building they have to go to does not have parking, so they’d have to walk a long distance to get there and battle winter weather every single week in order to participate. You may point out to the researchers that that’s a lot to ask of participants and suggest that the research team look at ideas to make it less of a burden, such as a financial incentive, transportation from the parking area, or even doing the blood draw at a more conveniently located lab.
An important topic for both members of the public and clinicians is that researchers should return to the communities that have been involved in the research to share the results of the study. This is referred to as dissemination, and it may be something you are asked to review.

Slide 9
[slide listing sustained engagement roles: participation in workgroups and committees, organizational representation, study team membership, and co-author or co-presenter roles]
Highly engaged Citizen Scientists are present in the day-to-day operations of a research study or an organization. Members can regularly attend meetings, they may bring reports of activities and progress back to a larger Citizen Scientist group. Including members of the Citizen Scientist team in research workgroups and committees ensures that the voice of the community is present in the decision making process.
As part of this high level of engagement, a Citizen Scientist may be invited to represent his or her organization at a national meeting or conference.
Some members may be asked to be involved in certain projects because they can offer a specific patient or individual perspective to that study. These Citizen Scientists may be written into the research study proposal as a member of the team and then they would be expected to participate in all meetings throughout the project’s life. As part of the study team, the Citizen Scientist may help write about the results of the study or present the findings to the community, funders, other researchers, or leaders at their organization. This was actually the case with Sharon Terry, who I mentioned earlier. She was often a co-author on research articles, and usually the only person listed who was not a doctor. She now has over a hundred published papers listing her as either the author or a co-author.

Slide 10
This statement was made by a clinician at the University of Florida who worked with Citizen Scientists. He valued their perspective and found it helpful in his work. Dr Rosenberg said:
“I was struck by how interested and receptive the Citizen Scientists were to explanations of why things are done the way they are in clinical care. They did not come with conclusions already in mind; rather, they had unanswered questions. When I have similar discussions with colleagues, it’s very different: we have our biases and predetermined notions of how things ought to be done that are based on how things have historically been done. This lack of rigidity makes them flexible and valuable partners in creating better clinical processes and stronger research agendas.”

Slide 11
In summary:
Citizen Scientists can be anyone, but it’s important that they represent their community
They can be involved in many different activities related to research
There are different levels of involvement for Citizen Scientists
In 2015, the federal government’s National Institutes of Health described the role of Citizen Scientists in biomedical research as “ordinary citizens in partnership with investigators” and they stated that this “redefines the current relationships between physicians, academic centers, and the public.”
From time to time, you might question how your involvement can make a difference in research. And sometimes giving your opinion may not seem that important. But we’ve learned that a Citizen Scientist can bring forth a point of view that researchers may never think about. It’s important for you to understand that it may not be easy to identify or measure your direct impact on a specific event; you are actively participating and providing your input on a regular basis, and therefore participating in a team science approach that considers all perspectives before making decisions.             
Thank you for watching.

Practice Activity

Instructions: After watching the video tutorial, complete the following practice assessment. Choose the best answer for each question, and check your response for immediate feedback.

FAQ

Note: The video refers to participants and/or the program as “Citizen Scientist,” which was the previous name of the Community Scientist Program.

Question:

What advice would you give to new Community Scientists?

Answer:

Additional Resources

  • Terry, S. F. (2003). Learning genetics. Health Affairs, 22(5), 166-171. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.22.5.166
    This narrative article, written by Sharon Terry, who you learned about in this presentation, describes the process her family went through as they tried to own and manage their own health data.
    Note: This article may be behind a paywall or login. If your organization grants access to journals, log in first, then use your credentials to find the journal.
  • Tips for New Community Scientists
    While some of the advice given is specific to the University of Florida program, the advice from current Community Scientists may help new members feel at ease and give input more freely in group settings.